Did Jesus die on the cross in our place?

Question:

Good day,

Did Jesus die on the cross in our place?

Thanks.

Answer:

When you see a statement not readily found in the Bible, examine it carefully. Sometimes the problem is that the terms used are different from those in the Bible. Sometimes an idea is implied but not stated directly. However, many times it is because what is being claimed is not biblical.

The claim that Jesus died on the cross in our place is commonly called "penal substitution."  It is the idea that one person takes on the punishment due to another person to free that person. "Christ died and took the penalty of our sins upon Himself. All sins of all mankind were imputed to Christ when He died on the cross, and they became His own" [Ben Taylor, "Penal Substitution"]. John Calvin was a strong supporter of this position: "Our acquittal is in this, that the guilt which made us liable to punishment was transferred to the head of the Son of God (Isaiah 53:12). We must specially remember this substitution in order that we may not be, all our lives, in trepidation and anxiety as if the just vengeance which the Son of God transferred to himself were still impending over us" [John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, 2:16:5].

The idea creates problems. If Jesus took all sin from all men at all times:

  • Everyone would be saved. Obviously, people have been lost, such as the rich man who went to torment. Calvin avoids the problem by claiming that salvation is limited to those God has selected. Thus, Christ did not die for all men, and so he only took all sin from some men (the ones God chose to save).
  • No one whom Christ died for would suffer any penalty because all their sins would be gone. Calvin again avoided this problem by claiming that when the Holy Spirit calls a person to be saved, sin no longer applies to him because Jesus paid it all. Going further, the claim is that the saved cannot sin, so there is no further penalty or consequence.

The position contradicts the Scriptures. Paul is clear that Jesus died for all men, not a limited set.  "For the love of Christ compels us, because we judge thus: that if One died for all, then all died; and He died for all, that those who live should live no longer for themselves, but for Him who died for them and rose again" (II Corinthians 5:14-15). His death was for the whole world. "My little children, these things I write to you, so that you may not sin. And if anyone sins, we have an Advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous. And He Himself is the propitiation for our sins, and not for ours only but also for the whole world" (I John 2:1-2). Notice that "world" is used in I John 2:2 and the context makes it clear that it cannot be limited to just believers. Jesus' death gave the entire world the potential for salvation. Whether they accept the gift given is up to them. Did Jesus die for my sins? Yes, but not only my sins. Did Jesus die for his people's sins? Yes, but not only for their sins. If that were true, no one else would have a chance to be saved. Jesus died for everyone's sins. "The Lord is not slack concerning His promise, as some count slackness, but is longsuffering toward us, not willing that any should perish but that all should come to repentance" (II Peter 3:9).

The idea that Christians cannot sin is also false. "If we say that we have no sin, we are deceiving ourselves and the truth is not in us. If we confess our sins, He is faithful and righteous to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. If we say that we have not sinned, we make Him a liar, and His word is not in us. My little children, I am writing these things to you so that you may not sin. And if anyone sins, we have an Advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous" (I John 1:8-2:1). The Christian should not sin, but the reality of the situation is that sin happens to even the best Christians.

A major source of the misunderstanding is verses that state that Jesus redeemed us from sin.

"For even the Son of Man did not come to be served, but to serve, and to give His life a ransom for many" (Mark 10:45).

Jesus paid the price necessary to release us from sin. However, this does not mean what was paid equaled what was owed. For example, a ram replaced Isaac as the offering to God (Genesis 22:13), but that doesn't mean the ram's life was equal in value to Isaac's.

When we sin, we earn death (Romans 6:23). The redemption price for everyone was the shed blood of a sinless man.

"But when Christ appeared as a high priest of the good things to come, He entered through the greater and more perfect tabernacle, not made with hands, that is to say, not of this creation; and not through the blood of goats and calves, but through His own blood, He entered the holy place once for all, having obtained eternal redemption. For if the blood of goats and bulls and the ashes of a heifer sprinkling those who have been defiled sanctify for the cleansing of the flesh, how much more will the blood of Christ, who through the eternal Spirit offered Himself without blemish to God, cleanse your conscience from dead works to serve the living God?"  (Hebrews 9:11-14).

Jesus' one death was sufficient to appease God's anger caused by all our sins. "And He Himself is the propitiation for our sins; and not for ours only, but also for those of the whole world" (I John 2:2).

When the Bible says that Jesus bore our sins, many people assume that he took on our sins, becoming temporarily sinful, and carried our sins away with him when he died.

"And He Himself bore our sins in His body on the cross, so that we might die to sin and live to righteousness; for by His wounds you were healed" (I Peter 2:24).

Peter is using phrases from Isaiah 53.

"Surely our griefs He Himself bore, and our sorrows He carried; yet we ourselves esteemed Him stricken, smitten of God, and afflicted. But He was pierced through for our transgressions, He was crushed for our iniquities; the chastening for our well-being fell upon Him, and by His scourging we are healed" (Isaiah 53:4-5).

Matthew quotes the same passage but applies it differently.

"When evening came, they brought to Him many who were demon-possessed; and He cast out the spirits with a word, and healed all who were ill. This was to fulfill what was spoken through Isaiah the prophet: 'He Himself took our infirmities and carried away our diseases'" (Matthew 8:16-17).

Jesus did not remove disease by absorbing the illnesses of people and then carrying them off. Matthew is indicating that Jesus shouldered the responsibility for removing diseases from people. In the same way, Jesus shouldered the responsibility for removing mankind's sins. It did not require him to become sinful to accomplish this task. In truth, he could not be sinful and still remove sin, since the requirement was a sinless life. Hebrews 9:14 says Jesus "offered Himself without blemish to God." I Peter 2:24 does not say Jesus bore our sins in his body. It says, "He Himself bore our sins in His body on the cross." This is how Jesus carried off our sins. He removed our sins through His body on the cross.

II Corinthians 5:21 is also frequently cited and misunderstood. In Matthew 27:46, Jesus said God abandoned him on the cross. People assume that God rejected Jesus because Jesus had become sinful through the carrying of all the world's sins. However, Matthew 27:46 only says that God left Jesus to die on the cross. It does not state why. II Corinthians 5:21 states that Jesus became "sin" or "a sin offering" (depending on the translation). It doesn't say this was why God forsook Jesus.

Regarding Jesus' statement on the cross, see: Does the phrase "Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani" have a different meaning in Aramaic than in Greek? Also, consider: Could Jesus have said, "My God, my God, for this I was kept"? where the word "forsaken" is discussed in greater detail.

"For He made Him who knew no sin to be sin for us, that we might become the righteousness of God in Him" (II Corinthians 5:21). This statement might appear contradictory on the surface. How can Jesus know no sin and be made sin for us? The answer is simple when you understand the Old Testament. Jesus was offered up as a sin offering. A sin-offering was the sacrifice of an unblemished animal for someone else's sins (Leviticus 4:3). The animal did not sin, nor did it take on the person's sins. Its death served as a payment for the sinner. Yet animals could not atone for men's sins. "For the law, having a shadow of the good things to come, and not the very image of the things, can never with these same sacrifices, which they offer continually year by year, make those who approach perfect. For then would they not have ceased to be offered? For the worshipers, once purified, would have had no more consciousness of sins. But in those sacrifices there is a reminder of sins every year. For it is not possible that the blood of bulls and goats could take away sins" (Hebrews 10:1-4). It took the sinless death of God's own Son to accomplish this. "By that will we have been sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all" (Hebrews 10:10).

II Corinthians 5:21 does not say that Christ became sinful or guilty of sin; that would contradict other passages (I Peter 1:19; 2:22; Hebrews 7:26; I John 3:5). Paul states that Jesus became the sin offering on our behalf. There are a number of verses in the Old Testament where the word “sin” is used to refer to the sin offering – the Hebrew word chattath can be translated as either sin or sin-offering; see Leviticus 4:23-24, where it is used both ways (Hosea 4:8; Ezekiel 44:29). In doing so, we are able to become righteous in Christ (Romans 5:19; Colossians 1:21-22). One way to read this is that Christ was treated as if he were sin, though he was without sin, so that we who are in him might be treated as if we were righteous, though we are sinful (Isaiah 53:12; I Peter 2:22-24). See also: Made to be Sin.