Is a recorded vocal song instrumental music?
Question:
Good day,
I recently read your article on listening to instrumental music. It argued that singing along to instrumental music outside of worship would be false worship.
I agree that, whether in the auditorium or outside it, instrumental worship is wrong. But if we can't sing a hymn for our own relaxation outside of worship, Wouldn't it be wrong to sing along to acapella recordings as well? Because the music now comes from machines, not humans. Yes, a human made the sound, but that was in the past, not in the present. And the command to sing was something continuous.
The scriptures themselves testify that recorded media can be used to admonish or teach, but singing must always come from the fruit of the lips.
If I write a song, I would have to sing it for it to be worship. If I record a song, I am no longer singing, though people might listen to it for a very long time; the music now comes from the machines, which is not authorized.
Just as it would be wrong to sing along to a cappella recordings in congregational worship, it would be wrong to sing along in private worship. Ephesians 5:19 and Colossians 3:16 say singing should be done to the Lord.
But if it is for leisure, for relaxation, or to admonish myself privately. it would not be wrong to sing a cappella; similarly, it would not be wrong to sing along to instrumentals. Because the music comes from the same source: a speaker, not voices and not even instruments.
Scripture gives several examples of singing for leisure; Solomon names it as a delight. James 5:11 says if any is happy, he should sing Psalms. If we say we have no authority to sing Psalms in leisure, should Christians only sing secular songs?
Answer:
I'm a bit puzzled about who you are arguing with. In "Is it okay to listen to instrumental 'Christian' music outside of worship?" I said that I personally choose not to sing songs to God when instruments accompany the singing. God defined how He is to be worshiped, and those rules apply whether you are in a worship assembly or worshiping privately. Since God specified vocal singing as the way He wants to be worshiped in the New Testament (Ephesians 5:19; Colossians 3:16), I don't seek to change it. I have friends who distinguish between public and private worship, but I don't.
Electronic amplification of voices is a modern technology. The ancients used acoustics to amplify the human voice, but the speaker had to stand in a specific spot. We can record the voice to be played back later. The Scriptures do not specify that speech can come from a recording, but I don't know of anyone who objects to listening to a recorded sermon. After all, if a message can be recorded on paper with ink, then an electronic verbal recording is just another format.
Songs have also been recorded in the Scriptures. For example, Psalm 109 is a song David wrote for the choir director. Asaph wrote Psalm 80, and he specified what tune to use with the words. Sadly, we don't know those tunes. However, a method of recording tunes has been developed, and we distribute music with the tunes attached. Like sermons, we now have the technology to record audio versions so people can listen and learn the songs. Whether a song is sung live or recorded to be played back later, it remains a capella singing.
Would I use a recorded song during worship? No. We have enough problems with people sitting back and letting others worship without providing more incentives to avoid participation in worship. Do I think it is wrong to sing a hymn while washing the dishes? Absolutely not! I wish more people would. "And at midnight Paul and Silas prayed, and sang praises unto God: and the prisoners heard them" (Acts 16:25). Singing hymns should not be limited to church services.
Since I don't agree that a recorded vocal song is instrumental music, I don't think singing along to an a cappella song at home is wrong.