Penal Substitution

by Jeffrey W. Hamilton

Text: Isaiah 53

 

I.         When you see a phrase or statement that isn’t readily found in the Bible, you ought to examine it carefully.

            A.        Sometimes, the problem is that the terms used are different from the Bible. The meaning is there but the exact wording is not.

            B.        Sometimes, an idea is implied but not directly stated.

            C.        However, many times you’ll find that what is being claimed isn’t biblical.

II.        Did Jesus die on the cross in our place?

            A.        The idea is commonly called “penal substitution.”

            B.        It is the idea that one person takes on the punishment due to someone else in order to free that person.

                        1.         “Christ died and took the penalty of our sins upon Himself. All sins of all mankind were imputed into Christ when He died on the cross, and they became His own.” [Ben Taylor, “Penal Substitution”, https://cedarparkchurchofchrist.org/resources/articles/2014/05/11/penal-substitution].

            C.        John Calvin strongly supported this position

                        1.         “Our acquittal is in this, that the guilt which made us liable to punishment was transferred to the head of the Son of God (Isaiah 53:12). We must specially remember this substitution in order that we may not be, all our lives, in trepidation and anxiety as if the just vengeance which the Son of God transferred to himself, were still impending over us.” [John Calvin, Institutes of Christian Religion, 2:16:5].

III.       Problems created by the idea

            A.        If Jesus took all sin from all men at all times, then everyone would be saved

                        1.         Obviously, people have been lost, such as the rich man went to torments

                        2.         To avoid this problem, Calvin claimed that salvation is limited to those God selected.

                                    a.         Thus, Christ did not die for all men, and so he only took all sin from some men (the ones God choose to save).

                                    b.         This position is called “Limited Atonement”

                        3.         Paul is clear that Jesus died for all men, not a limited set - II Corinthians 5:14-15

                                    a.         His death was for the whole world - I John 2:1-2

                                                (1)       Notice that “world” in verse 2 and the context is clearly not limited to just believers.

                                                (2)       Jesus’ death gave the entire world the potential for salvation

                                                (3)       Whether they accept his gift is up to them

                                                (4)       Did Jesus die for my sins? Absolutely, but no only my sins

                                                (5)       Did Jesus die for his people’s sins? Yes, but not only for their sins

                                    b.         II Peter 3:9 - Take note of the phrase “should come to repentance”

            B.        If Jesus took all sin from all men at all times, then those Christ died for would not suffer any penalty because all their sins would be gone.

                        1.         Calvin again avoided the problem by claiming that when the Holy Spirit calls a person to be saved, sin no longer applies to him because Jesus paid it all.

                                    a.         Going further, the claim is that the saved cannot sin, so there is no further penalty or consequence

                                    b.         This position is called the “Perseverance of the Saints” or more popularly “Once Saved, Always Saved.”

                        2.         Christians can sin - I John 1:8-2:1

                                    a.         They should not sin, but the reality of the situation is that sin happens, even to the best Christians

IV.      Misunderstood Passages

            A.        A ransom for many - Mark 10:45

                        1.         Jesus paid the price necessary to release us from sin

                                    a.         This doesn’t mean that what was paid equaled what was owed

                                    b.         A ram replaced Isaac as an offering to God - Genesis 22:13

                                    c.         But that doesn’t mean the ram’s life was equal value to Isaac’s

                        2.         When we sin, we earn death - Romans 6:23

                        3.         The redemption price for everyone was the shed blood of a sinless man - Hebrews 9:11-14

                        4.         Jesus’s one death was sufficient to appease God’s anger - I John 2:2

            B.        He bore our sins - I Peter 2:24

                        1.         Many assume that Jesus took on our sins, becoming temporarily sinful, and carried our sins away with him when he died

                        2.         Peter is using phrases from Isaiah 53:4-5

                                    a.         Matthew quotes the same passage but applies it differently - Matthew 8:16-17

                                    b.         Jesus did not remove disease by absorbing the illnesses of people and then carrying them off.

                                    c.         Matthew indicates that Jesus shouldered the responsibility for removing diseases from people

                        3.         In the same way, Jesus shouldered the responsibility for removing mankind’s sins.

                                    a.         It did not require him to become sinful to accomplish the task

                                    b.         He offered himself without blemish - Hebrews 9:14

                        4.         I Peter 2:24 doesn’t say Jesus bore our sins in his body.

                                    a.         It says “He Himself bore our sins in His body on the cross”

                                    b.         This is how Jesus carried off our sins. He removed our sins through his body on the cross.

            C.        Jesus was forsaken - II Corinthians 5:21

                        1.         Jesus said God abandoned him on the cross - Matthew 25:46

                                    a.         People assume that God rejected Jesus because Jesus had become sinful through the carrying of all the world’s sins.

                                    b.         However, it only states that God left Jesus to die on the cross; it does not state why.

                        2.         II Corinthians 5:21 says that Jesus became “sin” or “a sin offering” (depending on the translation)

                                    a.         It doesn’t say that this is why God forsook Jesus

                        3.         If you look at II Corinthians 5:21 carefully, it might appear contradictory

                                    a.         How can Jesus know no sin and be made sin for us

                                    b.         It is simple when you understand that Jesus was offered up as a sin offering

                                    c.         A sin offering was the sacrifice of an unblemished animal for someone’s sins - Leviticus 4:3

                                                (1)       The animal did not sin, nor did it take on the person’s sins.

                                                (2)       Its death served as a payment for the sinner

                                                (3)       Yet, animals couldn’t atone for men’s sins - Hebrews 10:1-4

                                    d.         It took the sinless death of God’s own Son to accomplish atonement for sin - Hebrews 10:10

                        4.         II Corinthians 5:21 does not say Christ became sinful or guilty of sin

                                    a.         Such would contradict - I Peter 1:9; 2:22; Hebrews 7:26; I John 3:5

                                    b.         Paul is saying that Jesus became the sin offering on our behalf

                        5.         There are several Old Testament passages where the word “sin” is used to refer to the sin offering

                                    a.         The Hebrew word chattath can be translated as sin or sin offering

                                    b.         Example: Leviticus 4:23-24 (also Hosea 4:8; Ezekiel 44:29)

V.        In offering himself as a sin offering, Jesus gave us a way to become righteous - Romans 5:19; Colossians 1:21-22

            A.        In a sense, Jesus was treated as if he were sin, though he was without sin, so that we who are in him might be treated as if we were righteous, though we are sinful - Isaiah 53:12; I Peter 2:22-24

            B.        Do you appreciate what Jesus did for you?

            C.        Are you availing yourself of his sacrifice?